Total Honkbal: The Baseball Team of Ajax Amsterdam

Late 1950s Amsterdam. A post-war generation grapples with boredom, awaiting with solemn fortitude the very revolution that would define it.

All around, denizens chase light relief from the daily grind, whizzing via bicycle to chosen hobbies that help pass the time, divert the gloom and stir the awakening.

A nascent pop culture attracts many to the cinema. Others listen to radio, hatching plans for life when the economy is fully recovered. But for one lanky kid, such slow-paced pursuits are definitively banal. Mr Cruyff needs fresh air and green fields in which to kick and throw and catch. Young Johan turns to baseball.

Johan Cruyff and baseball

We know him better as the leading exponent of Total Football, a Pythagoras in boots, an icon in the colourful rise of Dutch sophistication. But before he dominated European soccer with breathtaking ingenuity, Johan Cruyff fell in love with baseball.

A proficient catcher and occasional pitcher on the successful Ajax summer team, Cruyff gained a glowing reputation within baseball circles. At one point, his dominant performances piqued the interest of national selectors, who were keen for the future three-time Ballon d’Or winner to represent Oranje in youth baseball. A natural athlete, Cruyff excelled with immaculate technique while learning lessons in camaraderie and team spirit that were eminently transferable to his illustrious career.

The history of baseball at Ajax Amsterdam 

By the time Cruyff arrived at Ajax, the venerable club was an established force within Dutch baseball, or honkbal. As the twentieth century dawned, Ajax searched for a summer sport to compliment its successful football operation.

While the details are somewhat quixotic, many theorists point to Jack Kirwan as the founding father of Ajax baseball. Kirwan, an Englishman who steered Ajax to the top tier of Dutch football in 1911, first experienced baseball while playing for Tottenham Hotspur back home.

At that time, baseball was booming in Britain with investment from America supporting professional leagues intermittently. Many football teams adopted baseball as a means of recreation through the offseason and Kirwan won a National Championship with Spurs in 1906 ahead of Preston North End, Nottingham Forest and Derby County.

After assuming control of Ajax in 1910, legend holds that Kirwan introduced the sport to his players. By 1922, Ajax were founder members of Holland’s first formal honkbal league. In quirky competition with clubs like Blauw-Wit Amsterdam, SC Haarlem and Hercules, Ajax held their own.

De Amsterdammers won national titles in 1924, '28, '42 and '48. The baseball team, a vehicle for enhancing Ajax pride year-round, shared a smart facility with OVVO, one of the oldest clubs in Europe, and attracted modest crowds on warm summer days.

Johan Neeskens, Marco van Basten and the Ajax baseball academy

The spectators watched teams mainly comprised of youth footballers eager to maintain fitness through the lazy summer months when soccer took a backseat. Johan Neeskens was a fine ballplayer, perhaps even better than Cruyff.

Cor Wilders dominated for Blauw-Wit in football and honkbal, even twirling a no-hitter during his dual career. Joop Odenthal and Henk Schijvenaar joined him as the only players to represent Holland in both sports. Even Marco van Basten played baseball as a youngster, according to local legend, but few loved the game like Johan.

Where others saw it as mere fun, or a necessary evil mandated by the Ajax establishment, Cruyff developed a natural affection for baseball. To this day, he still refers to honkbal in his revered newspaper columns, often advocating its ability to teach the underlying values of unity and belief. 

In 2007, Cruyff attended the European Baseball Championships in his adopted Barcelona, watching with fascination as the Netherlands won their twentieth title. It resonated in the heart of a man who once illuminated Dutch diamonds with agility, elegance and spirit. It made him proud.

The relationship between baseball and soccer in Europe

Nowadays, the notion of football clubs endorsing a second sport is absurd. Such is the delicate procedure of insuring gargantuan contracts and choreographing the development of young players, paranoid clubs ban activities like skiing and rock-climbing and mountaineering.

The contemporary footballer is a sensitive figure. The perils of baseball would render the modern director of football apoplectic. Just imagine the scandal, uproar and carnage if a prized Arsenal academy graduate was hit in the head by a 90-mph fastball! The legal process would rage for months, years, decades. But Ajax operated in a different era. It was natural for Cruyff to stay alert by playing baseball. It was encouraged.

Could Johan Cruyff have played Major League Baseball?

Ultimately, he developed into the greatest European footballer of all-time, but the romantic in me often daydreams about how far Cruyff could have ventured in the world of baseball. He graced Number 14 for Ajax and Oranje, playing for Rinus Michels and alongside Neeskens, but could he have played for the Red Sox or Yankees or Giants, alongside Carl Yastrzemski or Mickey Mantle or Willie Mays? Could Fenway Park or Wrigley Field or Dodger Stadium have enshrined his retired number like Ajax did in 2007?

Probably not.

Cruyff was a one-off, a maestro, a man of skill and destiny on a football field. The course of Dutch history needed Johan startling with a ball and with outspoken temerity. On the diamond, he was just another guy who loved baseball. Just one of thousands throughout Holland, a nation highly-interested in the game.

All you need to know about honkbal, or baseball in Holland

The culture and customs of honkbal are unique, almost entirely independent of the popularised American game we adore. The essence of honkbal is unadulterated, its standing as a youthful summer sport well preserved throughout the Netherlands. Arguably, it can be seen as pure baseball, played with childlike enthusiasm and without gross commercialism.

The codified history of baseball in Holland can be traced to the early twentieth century, when JCG Grase, a Dutch schoolteacher, discovered it while on holiday in America. Upon returning home, Grase pitched baseball to his students as a summer alternative to soccer. The Amsterdam native even translated baseball’s rulebook and coined the term honkbal.

Ultimately, the game mushroomed in popularity, away from school courtyards and into elitist Holland. Soon, baseball became the preserve of dapper professionals, with the first organised club (Amsterdamsche Honkbal Club) comprised of doctors, entrepreneurs, lawyers and technicians.

A number of competing clubs sprang up throughout the country, with Hercules and Quick Amsterdam establishing strong identities. By 1934, honkbal was so popular as to facilitate a national match between Holland and Belgium.

During World War I, both ball-playing nations were unified by US and Canadian troops eager for baseball, the merging of leagues forming epic pennant races between teams from Rotterdam and Den Haag and Brussels.

Once combat stopped, the growing influence of baseball piqued the interest of football clubs such as Ajax who were keen for extraneous recreation. In turn, the involvement of top football clubs lent honkbal a certain credo, a clear seriousness that enabled the growth of a burgeoning domestic league and inspired more interest in the sport. To that end, 6,000 fans attended a Dutch-Belgian game held at Ajax’ De Meer Stadion in 1953. The game blossomed in Holland.

It helped that the Dutch were naturally-skilled ballplayers. Han Urbanus, a dominant pitcher who bewitched opposition batters to the tune of seven career no-hitters, attended Spring Training with the New York Giants in the early-1950s. While playing for Leo Durocher, Urbanus picked-up a wicked curveball from Sal Maglie, a bitter old warhorse who wouldn’t waste his time instructing a no-hoper. Indeed, Urbanus was offered a contract with New York, but he reneged citing practicality issues.

Nevertheless, the path was smoothed between Holland and America, honkbal and baseball. In time, top American coaches like Ron Fraser and Bill Acre were paid to teach the game throughout Holland. Urbanus’ ties to New York saw the Giants send instructional videos and pamphlets to the Netherlands, detailing how baseball should best be played and providing training methods for young players.

Accordingly, the level of skill improved and more Dutchmen followed in Urbanus’ footsteps in trying-out with modern Major League organisations. Robert Eenhoorn ventured from Rotterdam to become a Yankee. Rikkert Faneyte played in the same Giants’ outfield as McGee and Bonds. Wim Remmerswaal pitched for the Red Sox.

The Dutch became masters of European baseball.

Do Ajax still play baseball?

Ajax’ baseball operation ceased in 1972, when executives thought it more prudent to pump funds into a nascent football empire. However, at this point, modern honkbal had been born and Holland began to almost monopolised the European Baseball Championships. Consequently, the domestic league has enriched its infrastructure and quality to a point where a salary is now provided for most star players and foreign talent is axiomatic. It’s all a far cry from the innocent pastime that Johan Cruyff used to alleviate boredom, but Holland has become a model nation for would-be baseball programs.

Will Major League Baseball play games in Amsterdam?

Therefore, it’s only fitting that Major League Baseball is looking to the Netherlands as an ideal host for future games. A £15 million project has seen a 30,000-seat baseball stadium built to MLB specification in Hoofddorp, on the outskirts of Amsterdam. It’s hoped that Major League Baseball and the World Baseball Classic will visit for games here within the next couple of years.

Perhaps Mr Cruyff could throw out the ceremonial first pitch. After all, he may not have played professionally, but Johan remains the most iconic exponent in honkbal history.

Buy me a coffee

If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a digital tip. I do not believe in ads, subscriptions or paywalls, so please buy me a coffee to show your support. All contributions are greatly appreciated. Thank you.

Subscribe for free to receive all my writing straight to your inbox.

* indicates required

More from Ryan Ferguson

The people (and pets) named after Nomar Garciaparra
Exploring – and quantifying – the legacy of a Red Sox icon.
Read Now
Marilyn Monroe attended a Yankees game in 2006. No, really – she did!
A big league underdog, his mom with a famous name, and a storybook home run at Yankee Stadium.
Read Now
The Red Sox sued Doug Mientkiewicz for the 2004 World Series final out ball
Barbs, lawsuits and arbitration between a team and its unlikely protagonist.
Read Now
From the All-Star Game to prison with Esteban Loaiza, MLB ace turned drug lord
How a star pitcher swapped Yankee pinstripes for a khaki jail jumpsuit.
Read Now
Bobby Abreu once belonged to three MLB teams in four hours
From Houston to Philadelphia via Tampa Bay with an under-appreciated outfielder.
Read Now
Notes from New York
Recapping our 10-day honeymoon in The City That Never Sleeps.
Read Now
My all-forgotten Yankees team
The players you probably forgot wore pinstripes.
Read Now

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Social Proof Experiments