Disavowing Conflict, my own book

As we are told daily, the world has changed a lot since 2020. Sure, pandemics and political crises have transformed our collective landscape and changed our social discourse, but for me, the interim has been a period of deep and organic growth. So much so, I barely recognise the person I was three years ago, which is beautiful personally but problematic professionally. You see, I published a book in 2020, and I no longer believe in its founding hypothesis nor its immature conclusions. I have outgrown my own ill-conceived opinions – my own unrefined book – and it is time to set the record straight.

The book in question was Conflict, which explored my capricious fandom of various MLB teams and detailed the struggles of British baseball fans who lack natural rooting allegiances grounded in family tradition or simple geography. In particular, the book focused on my explosive oscillation between fandom of the Boston Red Sox and New York Yankees, mortal enemies at the apex of mutual hatred. I was unaware of a similar book existing anywhere else in the world, and now I probably know why.

What was the book about?

In a nutshell, for seven years, between 2004 and 2010, I was a maniacal Red Sox fan, only to endure an existential crisis when John Henry and Tom Werner – owners of the Boston franchise – purchased Liverpool FC (LFC), terminal rivals to Tranmere Rovers, my beloved hometown football club. To support Tranmere, a fourth division minnow, is to loathe Liverpool and Everton – the big, bad Premier League clubs who lurk six miles across the river Mersey – and that leviathan modality usurped my comparatively embryonic baseball fandom.

By dominating the regional market and hoovering up local fans, the exponential growth of LFC correlates instinctively and inexorably with the demise of Tranmere, my guiding light. Therefore, I could not abide any link – no matter how slender – to LFC, and my Red Sox fandom was instantly curtailed as a result. In my naïve teenage mind, Henry and Werner betrayed me by purchasing a football club I could not tolerate. They did not know I existed, of course, and nor did they care, but I quit being a Red Sox fan as quickly as their ownership jumped in bed with an organisation I abhorred. I was 16 years old at the time, and immaturity drove my reaction. I smashed up my Red Sox-themed bedroom and vowed never to root for the team again. Then, I fell in love with the Yankees – a once unthinkable notion.

How? While researching a feature on the Yankees’ collaboration with Manchester City in 2014, I reached out to the team’s press office, hoping to receive a stock quote about the joint venture. That line of inquiry ran dry, but my interest in baseball from across the pond caused a stir in the Yankees’ offices. Cristina Campana, a Yankees staffer, arranged for gifts – caps, t-shirts, pennants – to be sent by airmail, and upon receiving it, I was wooed by the allure of pinstriped mystique.

For seven years, I rooted for the Yankees in secret. If anybody knew, I would be vilified, ridiculed, lambasted and driven out of the game. I was not prepared to bear the inevitable backlash. I was too emotionally insecure, and I was too psychologically immature, to vocalise my forbidden passion. And so, I watched in silence, rooting for some awful Yankees teams while biting my tongue. The resultant anxiety compounded my deteriorating mental health, and I was entirely too bothered by what other people thought of me to live comfortably in my own skin.

Conflict was supposed to change all that. It was supposed to be a cathartic tell-all that set me free. I knew people would be irate, but I needed the therapy of piecing this whole thing together in my own mind. I needed to tell myself the full story. However, just three years later, the book has not aged well. It has aged horribly, in fact. For instance, in the conclusion, I declared lifelong allegiance to the Yankees after watching them sweep the Red Sox at the 2019 MLB London Series. Now, though, that edict has been broken. I’m still a Yankees fan, but not exclusively. I’m a fan of many teams, including the Yankees and Red Sox, and I’m no longer ashamed to admit it.

What is fluid sports fandom?

As explored in a recent essay, I’m now a fluid sports fan. What does that mean? Well, I enjoy many different – and often contradictory – teams without being identified by any specific one:

‘In many ways, for the past decade, I have lived in the gloom of internalised sports fan shame – a struggle similar to, though much less important than, that of a gender-fluid person yet to come out. The fear of scorn, bullying, judgement, cancellation, misunderstanding and mockery is near-ubiquitous, and a sufficiently safe outlet for expression rarely presents itself.

In many areas – gender, religion, sexuality – we are throwing off the shackles of regurgitated bigotry, but sports fandom seems beholden to ancient toxic strictures. Broadly, this is an age of emancipation, and everything is fluid nowadays, so why should our sporting allegiances be exempt from that phenomenon? I contend they should not. Rather, each individual should be allowed to enjoy sports however they want – free from ridicule and shame.

Though it is difficult for some cynics to comprehend, there are people out there who, like me, admire the Yankees and Red Sox. However, those people – exceedingly rare and admittedly unorthodox – lack the confidence and platform to vocalise their nonconformism. Ultimately, it is easier to internalise unpopular passions than to express them wholly, and that is a recipe for pent-up angst.

Traditionally, sports fandom was arbitrary and one-dimensional. Historically, our favourite teams were largely predetermined – chiefly by geographical proximity or familial kinship. One generation passed allegiances to the next like treasured heirlooms, and challenging the automated status quo carried serious consequences, including banishment and ostracisation. However, in a time of rampant globalisation, where our planet shrinks every day, those conventional catalysts of fandom are less influential. Whereas previous generations had access to few local sports teams, the complete digitisation of life provides the modern fan with instant, incessant access to all sports teams. Civic pride is suitably diluted, and a global market gnaws at our fingertips – Real Madrid and the Dallas Cowboys suddenly vying for the attention once monopolised by nearby minnows.

Sports are increasingly packaged and sold to us as entertainment, and maybe we should treat them as such. You would never stick exclusively to one streaming platform, or subscribe to a lone YouTube channel, so why bind yourself to one team per sport? There is a whole world out there – a free market, indeed, of clubs competing for the attention and affection of captive audiences. Fluid fandom – where consumers engage with different teams sporadically – is the logical endpoint of such a dynamic, and shopping around for value and contentment represents sound economics.’ – Coming out as a fluid sports fan, February 2023.

Angela Ruggiero has led this movement for years as the CEO and cofounder of the Sports Innovation Lab, which published a fascinating report in February 2020 – mere weeks before Conflict was published – that explained how sports fans have become more willing to change allegiances than their predecessors. “For decades, the sports and entertainment industry has operated differently than other businesses,” explained the report. “It has relied on enormously popular sports properties with generations of diehard fans defined by geography, loyalty, and rivalry. Despite this success, the diehard fan is not the path to growth for the sports and entertainment industry. There is a new path to growth, and that is the Fluid Fan. Fluid Fans are open to change, empowered to choose, and continuously evolving. They move from one form of entertainment to another. They consume sports media and content in shorter bursts of interest instead of longer, committed periods of ritualistic spectatorship.”

When I read that for the first time, and subsequently heard Angela expand on it in podcast interviews, it made my heart sing. For the first time in over a decade of lonely sports fandom, I felt heard. I felt free. ‘That is me,’ I thought. I’m a fluid fan. That is the itch I have been trying to scratch. Sure, I’m a Yankees fan, but I also like the Red Sox – stigma be damned. I love the work of Jared Carrabis and John Jastremski equally, and I will wear either cap – the interlocking NY or the crimson B – without fear. Other teams rotate in and out of my purview, too, and that is okay. That is totally fine. This is meant to be fun, after all, and I’m done apologising for the way I feel.

For years, I had a crude, antediluvian outlook on fandom – a polarised worldview anathema to my current strain of pragmatism. I remain loyal to Tranmere Rovers, and that affiliation will always provide a bedrock to my identity, but all other associations are now flexible. I have mellowed considerably, thawed by the perspective that comes with challenging personal life experiences. Sports are no longer an omnipotent force in my life. They are pure escapism – nostalgic pastimes to be enjoyed – and I have stopped ascribing them further meaning.

Why you should stop caring who owns your favourite sports teams

Indeed, as detailed in another recent piece, I now embrace a more secularised vision of sports, separating ownership from front office and front office from the field. At the confluence of barefaced greed and private equity conflicts, I advocate a laissez-faire approach to modern fandom. Rather than fighting monolithic corporations and uber-rich executives with bottomless resources, I suggest circumventing them entirely to reclaim control of your sports fan emotions:

‘An argument can be made that sports fans must protect themselves from the fruits of inauthentic billionaire largesse, just as cult survivors must insert safeguards in their daily operations. How, though? One radical suggestion? Stop caring who owns your favourite sports teams, because they are probably scumbags. And, even if they are not scumbags, they are probably somehow connected to or reliant upon scumbags deep in the compromised supply chain. The sporting powerbrokers – commissioners, CEOs, presidents – do not seem to care who owns what, so why should we? Perhaps we should not.

Maybe we should root for the team, not the owner. Drill down a level in your criteria for picking teams to support and stories to adore. Rather than bickering about polished executives, celebrate mud-caked players. Rather than expending energy on payrolls and politics, enjoy home runs and ranging plays into the shortstop gap. Rather than worrying about luxury tax penalties, watch the actual game. You may fall in love with it all over again.’ – Why sports team owners suck, November 2022.

The current average tenure among Major League Baseball owners is 22 years. Henry and Werner have owned the Red Sox since 2001. There are few signs they intend to relinquish control. In my more combative youth, I vowed to wait them out – to boycott Boston baseball until they sold – but I no longer have the energy to hold that grudge. Fenway Sports Group will likely control the Red Sox until I’m a middle-aged man, perhaps even until I’m retired. There is nothing I can do to change that, so getting worked up about it is a recipe for incurable disgruntlement. 

To that end, rather than fighting unwinnable battles against oblivious mercenaries, I now enjoy sports – particularly baseball – on my own terms, within my own context, without recourse to binary declarations and all-encompassing categorisations. I have enjoyed rooting for the Red Sox and Yankees this season, for example. Triston Casas and Alex Verdugo are fun to watch, as are Aaron Judge and Anthony Volpe. I’m tired of second-hand cognitive dissonance shrouding that enjoyment. I’m sick of applying caveats to all my baseball opinions. I’m done rehashing Conflict, hence this heartfelt disavowal.

Disavowing and unpublishing my own book

Ultimately, I have just grown up a lot in recent years, and rigid sports fandom – tribal, toxic, bitter sports fandom – has no place in my current philosophy. Since publishing Conflict, I have experienced true, deep, organic and inexplicable growth. Not from a self-help book or life hack listicle. Not from a YouTube guru or self-proclaimed life coach. But from within. From realising who I am. From understanding baseball is a pleasant distraction – a lyrical pastime, indeed – rather than a holy war. From making mistakes and being vulnerable and failing – and still having the bravery to strip everything back and live my truth. To be me, no matter what anyone else thinks.

There are still parts of Conflict I’m proud of, and I will likely reuse certain passages in future projects, but overall, the book no longer represents me, and so I have unpublished it – a sequestered benefit of self-publishing. Conflict is now essentially out of print, because the sanctity of my authentic story is worth more than any passive income it may attract. I thank everyone who bought the book, and I hope you still enjoy it. I could have written a sequel, but that did not feel right, so please view this piece as an appendix. It brings closure to 13 years of purgatory.

It takes a lot to admit you were wrong. It is one of the most chafing ordeals in the human experience. As such, retracting a 443-page book opens a sea of vulnerability – accessed by peeling back layers of cringe, shame and humiliation. But to set the record straight is liberating. When all is said and done, I’m not who I was in 2016, or 2019, or 2020, so removing inaccurate literary footprints from those eras is relieving.

Of course, an argument can be made for keeping Conflict available, in the interest of etymological traceability. After all, art is the residue of imperfection, so mapping one’s creative evolution can be considered poetic. However, my current views are so diametrically opposed to those contained within the book that issuing a repudiation feels apt. By cleansing all those failed half-versions of myself from the public record, I can own my real story. My current story. More importantly, perhaps, I can make space for new perspectives, experiences and energy.

Though rarely acknowledged or discussed, many writers have endured such ambivalence towards their work. Annie Proulx regretted writing Brokeback Mountain when the film adaptation mangled her original message. AA Milne loathed Winnie the Pooh because it cast his other work in a juvenile shadow. Gay Talese twisted himself inside out grappling with The Voyeur’s Motel, struggling to corroborate the claims of its eponymous protagonist. Even Stephen King has expressed regret over certain entries in his expansive bibliography. Ideas, like opinions, come and go, wax and wane, change and morph. We should remember that before cancelling authors for sharing unvarnished opinions – especially those expressed many years ago, when they were fundamentally different people.

The future of my sports fandom

In telling this story, I have derived great motivation and inspiration from the LGBTQIA+ community – especially those who identify as gender-fluid. Equating mere baseball allegiance with any of those core concerns is myopic, but the spirit of discovery and emancipation fostered by that brave movement is certainly mutual to my journey:

‘For over a decade, I worried and fretted about the many teams in my passionate penumbra, trying to minimise affiliations and delete stray feelings. In many ways, my struggle was dysphoric: I felt a profound sense of unease and dissatisfaction with my identity as a sports fan. Yet with maturity came self-understanding, and with self-understanding came confidence. Contrary to minimalist decluttering, so sacrosanct in our milieu, I now believe more can sometimes make us happier – by obliterating the arbitrary rules that deprive us of spontaneous joy.

As such, you do not have to explain why you like specific sports teams. You do not have to caveat every opinion or qualify every exultation. You do not have to pay taxes in Los Angeles to cheer for the Dodgers, nor do you have to be a Michigan graduate to wear a Wolverines hoodie. You do not need German ancestors to appreciate Bayern Munich, nor do you require season tickets to validate a passionate opinion about Celtic or Rangers. Stop playing that game. Stop complying with that charade. Stop rewriting history to make the present more bearable. Instead, become a fluid fan. Wear what you want. Watch what you want. Cheer when you want, for whoever you want, at whatever volume you want. Let your heart explore freely, rather than welding it to a set course.

Some people like apples. Some people like oranges. Some people like both. Some people liked apples as a kid but grew to prefer oranges as an adult. Some people liked oranges as a teenager then appreciated apples as a pensioner. Some people prefer grapes to apples or oranges. And the beautiful thing is that nobody can say who is right or wrong. Nobody can dictate your truth. So live and let live. Grow up and move on. Have the courage to stop holding yourself back.’ – Coming out as a fluid sports fan, February 2023.

In that spirit, I will continue to fearlessly express myself – to write about the Yankees and Red Sox, the Dodgers and Giants, the Cardinals and Cubs. I will write about anything – any team or any player – that piques my interest. I may even refer to myself as a fan of various teams, because I am, ultimately. Though many will try, nobody can tell me – or you – how to be a sports fan. Likewise, nobody can tell me – or you – how to identify on any given day. Gone is the epoch of exclusivity, replaced by the age of inclusivity. Let it flow, people. Let it be. Life is too short to suppress your true self.


Buy me a coffee

If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a digital tip. I do not believe in ads, subscriptions or paywalls, so please buy me a coffee to show your support. All contributions are greatly appreciated. Thank you.



More from Ryan Ferguson

The 26 most sacred skate spots of all-time
Once you start thinking like a skateboarder, the world never looks the same.
Read Now
A prodigal son, Tom Ince is Tranmere's biggest name for a generation
How the return of a local star has reinvigorated Rovers fans.
Read Now
When the Dodgers hired Vladimir Shpunt, a Russian mystic, to send positive vibes
Soviet science, energetic healing, the bankrupt Dodgers, and a hermetic wizard.
Read Now
When Jerry Jones tried to buy a stake in the Miami Dolphins
The ultimate Cowboy and his forgotten Florida foray.
Read Now
How Mariano Rivera saved Enrique Wilson’s life by blowing Game 7 of the 2001 World Series
A rare blown save, the end of a Yankee dynasty, and a deep twist of fate.
Read Now
Daydreaming a fantasy consortium to buy the Boston Red Sox
A futile, academic exercise to topple John Henry.
Read Now

1 comment

  • Interesting piece you are probably more of a true Baseball fan than most despite not being a die hard of One team . I don’t really follow a Premier league team but can enjoy watching certain teams , but those teams change managers & players frequently, it doesn’t affect my life or even my mood , its just entertainment.

    Mike Head

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Social Proof Experiments